• Banner 3
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 1

Welcome to Just Pies

Just Pies, a bakery located in Westerville, OH, offers a wide variety of delicious pies, including fruit, cream, and savory pot pies. Customers rave about the fresh and generously filled pies, highlighting favorites like the Peach Riot and Butterscotch. The friendly staff, easy ordering process, and cute store ambiance add to the overall enjoyable experience. Notable mentions include the use of lard in the exceptional pie crusts and the convenience of pre-ordering for holidays. Whether you're craving a sweet treat or a hearty meal, Just Pies is the go-to spot for all things pie-related.

Just Pies: Reviews & Ratings

Rob C.
Rob C.

Hot one of their chicken pot pies and an apple crumble pie for desert. Both were excellent and I would highly recommend. Place is always busy, so plan to get there early for the best selection.

Mark M.
Mark M.

Great pies. Meat or fruit. Reminds me of the old mountain top pies. Good crust. Don't wait to long on weekend, they go fast.

Jay S.
Jay S.

Great pies. They are experts at what they make and it's pretty simple to understand........ just pies. Great staff, friendly service, and amazing pies of all types and varieties. I've never bought a pie I didn't eat from Just Pies!!!

Kenedy W.
Kenedy W.

Really good pies and good prices. The associates here are very kind and helpful. They always have amazing free samples, and their pies are good every single time, no matter what I get. Easy in and out location, but it doesn't hurt to call and check that your pie is in stock, because they're known to be very good and do sell out!!

Bev B.
Bev B.

The buckeye pie was absolutely delicious! It must be one their best sellers as I got the last small pie, and I got there before noon. The pie was lite and not too sweet--just right. I sliced my pie and put in the freezer, and I can actually say, it was even better eating frozen/semi-frozen. It was like eating a pie, ice cream, and candy bar ( peanuts and chocolate chip topping) all at once--what a treat! I can't wait to try some of the other cream pies. I bought a small frozen peach pie, frozen chicken and small turkey pot pie that I have not tried yet. I appreciate them having small pies. Customer service was excellent. Store was bright and clean.

Melanie S.
Melanie S.

There's just two words for Just Pies - Just Go! They make amazing pies. I love the peach/berry Peach Riot, and also enjoy the cream pies - chocolate, coconut, etc. All of the pies are generously filled and ultra fresh. They do and will sell out. Either go early, or you can pre-order, which is highly recommended if you want a certain kind. What I really love is that they make a 6 inch size that's just right for a couple of days of pie for one person as well as full sized! Also, don't sleep on the pot pies. They are fantastic! They make a normal chicken pot pie, a dark meat chicken, and a chicken/broccoli/cheese number, all of which I have purchased multiple times and will again. Again, these come in the small and large sizes. The pot pies are sold frozen, and take about an hour to cook, so factor that into your calculations. Please also note - they do use lard in their crust. While I don't normally eat pork, I do make an exception for the best frigging pie crust in the city. No joke. You can also pick up their wares at some of the local grocery stores around town, so if you see them, take advantage, though a trip to the Mother Ship is always a good idea!

Angela M.
Angela M.

Yummy! Big selection! A local family business. All different kinds of fruit, cream and even chicken pies! Don't go hungry! Order in advance for holidays.

Jim H.
Jim H.

Just Pies is just that - PIES. Fruit pies, pumpkin pies, cream pies. speciality pies, "no sugar added" pies and pot pies. We normally spend Thanksgiving with the kids and grandkids in Kentucky and it's my job to bring the pies. They don't take reservations for the holidays and it's "first come - first served". So, I headed over around 9am and got in at the end of a line that stretched to the end of the building. The line moves fast and I was on the way home with pies in less than 45 minutes. This year we had an APPLE and a PECAN pie - both were exceptional. This past summer we had guests coming and one was on a "no sugar" diet. I went to Just Pies and bought FROZEN PEACH pies that had no sugar. They were excellent and we never missed the sugar. A friend tipped to how he does pies (this works for fruit pies but not cream pies). He goes before the holiday rush and buys the frozen version of the fruit pies and then just follows the instructions to bake them on Thanksgiving. Saves standing in line.

Chris W.
Chris W.

This was my first trip to just pies after hearing raving reviews over the past year. It did not disappoint. I had a beef pot pie which isn't at all like the poor pot pies we grew ip with. It was more like a pot roast in a pie crust. It was pure deliciousness. I also purchased an apple crumble pie and the peach riot pie. The peach riot is an amazing pie consisting of peaches, blueberries and cherries. The kids loved it. The apple crumble reminded me of a better version of my moms pie growing up.....shhh...don't tell her but it's true. I'll be back for sure!

Diana P.
Diana P.

I'm so happy I found this place! I ordered a small butterscotch pie for my boyfriend's birthday and he loved it. It's the perfect size for one person to eat over a couple of days. The flavor was delicious and not overly sweet. It was pretty too! A+ for appearance. It was super easy to place an order. I called with my order and was on the phone for probably less than a minute. Pickup was just as easy. The actual store is cute. It's small, but packed with lots of pies and smells fantastic. I'm very pleased with my pie and the price I paid. I will absolutely order from here again. I can't wait to try the lemon meringue!

Location

  • Just Pies
    736 Northfield Rd Ste 1 Westerville, OH 43082 Hotline: (614) 818-9300

Welcome to Just Pies, where the name says it all - they specialize in making delicious pies! This family-owned bakery located in Westerville, Ohio, offers a wide variety of fruit, cream, and savory pies that are sure to satisfy any craving.

Customers rave about the quality and taste of the pies at Just Pies. From classic apple crumble to unique flavors like peach riot and buckeye pie, there is something for everyone to enjoy. The crust is praised for being flaky and delicious, and the fillings are generously packed with fresh ingredients.

Not only do they offer a mouthwatering selection of pies, but Just Pies also provides excellent customer service. Visitors appreciate the friendly staff and convenient ordering process, making it easy to indulge in their favorite pies.

Whether you're in the mood for a sweet dessert or a savory pot pie, Just Pies has you covered. Don't miss out on the opportunity to try these delectable treats for yourself - your taste buds will thank you!